Who is a journalist?

As cases continue cropping up raising the question of whether bloggers’ deserve the protection of the “reporter’s privilege” and other rights traditionally reserved for professional journalists, Slate’s Jacob Weisberg has a very enlightened take on the question of who is a journalist in this new world order:

Those who advocate a special legal privilege for journalists must accept that anyone who thinks he’s a journalist is a journalist, and figure out how to protect the activity rather than a defined group of people. Properly understood, journalism has never been simply a trade or a profession. In a democracy like ours, it’s a basic right.

COMMENTS

  • Lex

    Yes. Precisely. Journalism is a behavior, and the presence or absence of that behavior determines whether one is a journalist in any particular context.

    The Framers got it right. We should, too.

  • JOnny

    Absolutely correct. This is a terrible thing that the fourth estate must confront with tooth and claw.

  • judiju

    that makes sense,because if anyone who says they’re a journalist is one.. they’re following certain practices that are widely recognized

    blogging is just a new way of performing an old craft… its not a profession but it is a craft.. like shoemaking

    if you forget to stitch the soles to the rest of the shoe, it’s not going to be a very good shoe